Comics, Mangas, And Graphic Novels Are The Same | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
Arts Entertainment

Comics, Mangas, and Graphic Novels Are the Same

So relax and enjoy them for what they are.

326
https://cdn.pixabay.com/photo/2016/12/28/03/45/ice-sculptures-1935352_960_720.jpg
Mariamichelle | Pixabay

Chances are you've heard of the terms "comic books," "mangas," and "graphic novels." Will Eisner, responsible for popularizing the term "graphic novels," made a goal for comics to be seen as literature with critically acclaimed stories like "A Contact With God." Since then, writers like Art Spiegelman who wrote the classic "Maus," adopted the term to refer allegedly to a more mature form of comics.

Manga is important to Japanese art culture—many will be familiar with the original comics or anime adaptations of "Dragon Ball," "Sailor Moon," and "One Piece." It doesn't change the fact that calling these comics is still correct.

A comic is a story often told with visuals in multiple panels. Comic strips, comic books, graphic novels, and Mangas all have this, making them comics.

Take Charles Schulz's "Peanuts," one of the world's most popular four panels consisting of Charlie Brown and his friends' misadventures. Through decades of change within the characters and numerous re-releases of books, including the fantastic Fantagraphics Books, one could argue that these are comic books, graphic novels, or even manga if you read a Japanese translation.

It does not change the fact that "Peanuts" tells its stories through visuals, accompanied by speech bubbles and panels.

As for Manga—remember that the English translation of Manga (漫画 in Japanese using Kanji characters) is "comics." That means if someone reads Superman, an American creation in a Japanese translation, especially in Japan, they are reading a Manga. That doesn't mean they are wrong for calling Superman a comic, certainly not more so than reading a Dragon Ball comic in English oversea and calling it a comic book. There are no art styles exclusive to Japan, America or any other nations.

It's like arguing that anime is a different media from animation, when the only difference is that anime animation made in Japan.

Further confusing is the false assumption that comic books and graphic novels are somehow different. Doing so implies that comic books is inherently juvenile while graphic novels is the sophisticated medium made for adults. Despite this, nothing stops a comic book from being mature or a graphic novel from being childish.

It certainly hasn't stopped the Japanese comic industry from categorizing their comics into five different sections, kodomo (children), shonen (teenage males), shojo (teenage females), seinen (adult male), and josei (adult women), and still calling all of it comics.

Had Eisner not distributed "A Contract With God" through bookstores instead of comic shops that were popping up (granted not without justifications), there would be no doubt that graphic novels are comics.

There's no shame in calling a comic a comic. Either way, it's the medium that follows the most beloved gang of children being mean to each other like in "Peanuts," or follows the journey of a middle-aged man who lost his parents at a young age and now fights crime against Gotham's worst enemies like in Batman. It's the search for seven mystical Dragon Balls to grant a wish like in "Dragon Ball," or provide thoughtful commentary on the decline of superheroes in "The Watchmen."

So relax and enjoy them for what they are.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
singing
Cambio

Singing is something I do all day, every day. It doesn't matter where I am or who's around. If I feel like singing, I'm going to. It's probably annoying sometimes, but I don't care -- I love to sing! If I'm not singing, I'm probably humming, sometimes without even realizing it. So as someone who loves to sing, these are some of the feelings and thoughts I have probably almost every day.

Keep Reading...Show less
success
Degrassi.Wikia

Being a college student is one of the most difficult task known to man. Being able to balance your school life, work life and even a social life is a task of greatness. Here's an ode to some of the small victories that mean a lot to us college students.

Keep Reading...Show less
Lifestyle

6 Signs You're A Workaholic

Becuase of all things to be addicted to, you're addicted to making money.

316
workaholic
kaboompics

After turning 16, our parents start to push us to get a job and take on some responsibility. We start to make our own money in order to fund the fun we intend on having throughout the year. But what happens when you've officially become so obsessed with making money that you can't even remember the last day you had off? You, my friend, have become a workaholic. Being a workaholic can be both good and bad. It shows dedication to your job and the desire to save money. It also shows that you don't have a great work-life balance. Here are the signs of becoming a workaholic.

Keep Reading...Show less
10 Life Lessons For The Camp Counselor
madison miller

Spending five, 10 or even more weeks in the outdoors leading elementary to high school aged kids for a week at a time is unique, to say the least. You see things in yourself you didn't think were there and experience emotions you can not explain. What you learn is valuable for more than just camp, but extends to life after the summer.

Keep Reading...Show less
Student Life

Things You Can Get Away With Now That You're At College

83% of my trends in college would have been shamed in high school.

1805
college life
Google Images

Transitioning from high school to college can be a stressful experience, especially if you're like me and hate change. Over the past two years I've realized there's many things I couldn't get away with in High School that are typically applauded in college.

1. Eat

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments