Why Andrew Yang's Universal Basic Income Is Doomed To Fail
Start writing a post
Currently

Why Andrew Yang's Universal Basic Income Is Doomed To Fail

Rather than focusing on a "one-size-fits-all" scenario, candidates should direct their attention to targeted support citizens on poverty level actually need.

66
Why Andrew Yang's Universal Basic Income Is Doomed To Fail

In a nutshell, Andrew Yang's version of Universal Basic Income would guarantee $1,000 per month to every individual over the age of 18, with no prior requirements, which makes it surprisingly different than welfare. Yang isn't the first to introduce UBI though, the idea of it has been reappearing in American elections since the 1960s. The main focus around implementing UBI is to prevent a nationwide crisis from ensuing as a result of the new wave of automation, which Yang claims will have a greater negative impact on the economy than previous periods of automation.

It sounds like a dream! It would not only reduce poverty but also balance the unfair distribution of wealth. If you can't fight automation, new ways are needed to prevent more and more unqualified Americans from losing their jobs, right?

Wrong.

Here's where the issue starts, UBI has been tried before a couple of times, and the results were not the best.

In April 2005, what is now known as the Basic Income Grant Coalition was formed in Namibia, originally mentioned by Evangelical Lutheran Church in the Republic of Namibia and a handful of non-governmental organizations. A proposal to try and convince the Namibian government to enforce the system of UBI was created, though it was ultimately rejected. They had hoped it would not only ease the uncontrollable levels of inequality, but it would also lessen poverty.

Later in 2008, the BIG coalition established a mock project in the village of Otjivero, in which they paid every resident a monthly amount of 100 Namibian Dollars (around $6.94). Funded by different establishments in Germany, the project costed nothing for the Namibian Government, yet they remained reluctant to adapt to a system this skeptical. The project had continued until September 2012, their cash value given out had significantly decreased, and they heavily relied on private donations. At first, the results seemed highly beneficial, but they were later proven unsustainable and somewhat inconclusive, stating that many methodological flaws and loopholes were present. Basically, It was bound to fail from the moment it was released. Namibia isn't alone, Finland and India are both countries with similar results from UBI experiments conducted.

While UBI is supposed to help decrease poverty, it might actually do the exact opposite. The funding for UBI will obviously have to come from every citizen since everyone is getting the benefits, but it's ironic how funding will be taken from the poor to help stop the poor.

Rather than focusing on a "one-size-fits-all" scenario, candidates should direct their attention to targeted support citizens on poverty level actually need.

In today's fast-paced, competitive market, an incentive to work has been stronger than ever. Implementing Universal Basic Income will eliminate that incentive for many, proceeding to a lack of motive to work which will inevitably affect the economy in ways we cannot even imagine.

The reality is Universal Basic Income seems to support more STEM skill sets which will be more favorable in the next decade, but the fact of the matter is, not everyone is capable of only being an engineer or an entrepreneur, and it's not everyone's desire to do so. Our economy thrives on jobs with different skill sets like plumbing or cooking, and trying to take that away using UBI will do more harm than good.

In the end, Univeral Basic Income just isn't the right solution.

Report this Content
Featured

How Technology Has Changed Our Lives

While we are all very dependant on technology, we are losing touch with humanity.

2556
How Technology Has Changed Our Lives

If we look back on how our ancestors lived we can sense a totally different lifestyle. If they could come back and live with all our technological devices they surely would think they are in a completely new alien world. They lived such a simple life without our devices that it seems as if centuries have passed by. In reality most of the discoveries were accomplished in the past twenty years. Indeed we have assisted a total technological distortion. This change in our lives was characterized by a myriad of technological innovations, due to globalization.

Keep Reading...Show less
Sports

Why I Love Football

Why Is Football A Sport That Is So Celebrated Across The Nation?

5775
College quarterback drops back to make pass as football season begins
https://pixabay.com/en/quarterback-american-football-sport-67701/

It is the time of year when the athletic event of football tends to exhilarate fans across the Nation. Why is football a sport that is so celebrated across the Nation? Many times I have asked myself why I even love the game of football so much, especially being a female, but I came up with a few of the many reasons why football fans love the game. though this may not be everyone's reasons for loving the game, here are some reasons that I love football.

Keep Reading...Show less
Student Life

Nostalgic Early 2000s Barbies: 34 Forgotten Treasures

For all the 90's babies and their obsession with Barbies.

30425
Barbies on a display case
LATimes

With Barbie mania overtaking society with the release of the new movie, here is some late 90's/early 2000's nostalgia for you in Barbie form.

It's sure to stir up old memories and unlock some good ones. And if you're feeling inspired by a particular toy but you don't remember where you put it, we've listed where you can find one today. You're welcome.

Keep Reading...Show less
Featured

Riots and Protests rock Paris and other French cities

Crazy European Summer

1306
Riots and Protests rock Paris and other French cities
A 17 year old boy of North African origin was shot and killed by French police during a traffic stop on Tuesday. The police claimed they "feared for their lives" when the boy started driving away from them and opened fire, killing him.
Keep Reading...Show less
Featured

When DEI goes haywire

Shocking Revelation: Doctors Resort to Ethnicity-Based Prioritization in Medical Care

1551
When DEI goes haywire
In a shocking move in New Zealand, surgeons must now consider ethnicity in prioritizing patients for operations.
Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments