Supreme Court Rules Trump's Taxes May Be Investigated
Start writing a post

Trump's Tax Returns May Finally Be Investigated After A 7-2 Supreme Court Ruling

Both justices the president appointed ruled against him.

Trump's Tax Returns May Finally Be Investigated After A 7-2 Supreme Court Ruling

In a ruling on Thursday morning, the majority of the Supreme Court concluded that President Donald Trump is not immune to grand jury subpoenas.

The New York District Attorney's office, acting on behalf of a grand jury, issued a subpoena to Donald Trump for his financial records, including eight years of his tax returns. The subpoena was issued in connection with the investigation into payments made by the President to Stormy Daniels and Karen McDougal, who Trump allegedly had affairs with before he took office.

The President attempted to block the subpoena, with his attorneys arguing that he had absolute immunity from all criminal investigations while in office. The Department of Justice instead argued in Trump v. Vance (2020) that the President does not have absolute immunity, but that if prosecutors wish to subpoena the President's information they must meet a high standard in court that proves they need to do so. The Court rejected that argument.

Trump-appointed Justices Neil Gorsuch and Brett Kavanaugh joined Chief Justice John Roberts and the liberal justices in the decision which held the decision of the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit that "Article II and the Supremacy Clause do not categorically preclude, or require a heightened standard for, the issuance of a state criminal subpoena to a sitting president." This is a major victory for the New York District Attorney's Office and for other prosecutors attempting to subpoena the president's information.

In another decision, the Supreme Court ruled that Congress cannot get Trump's financial records — for now.

In the 7-2 decision in Trump v. Mazars (2020), the Court sent the case back down to the lower courts and orders them to take "adequate account of the significant separation of powers concerns" implied in the Congressional subpoenas. The case involved separate subpoenas issued by three different Congressional committees, The Committee on Oversight and Reform, The Committee on Financial Services, and the House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence, each with their own legislative reasoning. The subpoenas were issued to three different financial institutions that each have access to Trump's financial records, his accounting firm Mazars USA LLC, Deutsche Bank, and Capital One. The D.C. Circuit and the Second Circuit courts both ruled in the House Democrats favor, and this case goes back to them to decide if Congress can legally subpoena the financial records without causing an imbalance in power between the branches of government.

It is likely that Trump's attorneys will raise new concerns and draw out this litigation.

Although Trump v. Vance (2020) was ruled in favor of the New York District Attorney, Cyrus Vance, that does not mean that the public or the DA will see Trump's tax returns soon. Trump's legal team is going to raise new Constitutional concerns in an attempt to bar the release of the documents. If the records are released to the DA, the public will not see them. Any documents subpoenaed in grand jury investigations must be kept secret by law.

The President has continuously refused to release his tax returns to the public, prompting widespread speculation about what is contained in them. The only window the public has gotten into Trump's financial records came as the result of a Pulitzer-Prize winning New York Times investigation that delved into Fred Trump Sr.'s, Donald Trump's father, tax returns. It was recently revealed that those tax returns and family financial records were supplied by Donald Trump's niece, Mary Trump.

It may be a long time before we see any of Donald Trump's personal tax returns if his legal team can keep stalling the judicial process.

Report this Content

Keep Reading... Show less

T-Mobile is facing two class-action lawsuits as a result of a catastrophic data breach.

Lawsuits are piling up in the wake of the massive data breach.


Two class-action lawsuits have been filed against T-Mobile in the wake of a massive data breach that left millions of customers' personal information exposed.

Keep Reading... Show less

Biden's Inauguration Signals A Time Of Healing After A Dark And Painful Period

Joe Biden's inauguration marks the beginning of a time of healing for America.


The day finally arrived. Joe Biden has been inaugurated and is now the 46th president of the United States of America. Kamala Harris has been sworn in as our country's new vice president. She is the first woman and the first person of color to fill the role. After years of fighting, frustration, and fear, this is a day of celebration. It's a day of hope as we look to the future. It's also a day of healing, as our collective wounds are still very fresh.

Keep Reading... Show less

Victory For LGBTQ Americans As The US Gains 6 New LGBTQ Government Representatives

Regardless of who is president, let's celebrate these huge victories for LGBTQ representation in various states' governments.


The presidential election was extremely stressful for us all, causing us to worry about who will win and what it means for the future. For many of us, this can mean the difference between life and death, especially for BIPOC and members of the LGBTQ communities who are at the mercy of homophobes and racists — many of whom are proud supporters of the color orange.

Instead of worrying whether I'll be sent to a conversion camp next year or not, I'd rather celebrate the much bigger and more important wins. There have been six representatives added to state governments this past election who are all a part of the LGBTQ community.

Keep Reading... Show less

Who Said It — Donald Trump Or A Villain From The Avatar Universe?

A hilarious and frightening game of who said it: Donald J. Trump or a villain from "Avatar: The Last Airbender" or "The Legend of Korra."

Gage Skidmore / Flickr Creative Commons; Nickelodeon

Have fun guessing whether outgoing President of the United States Donald J. Trump or a literal anime villain said each of these 26 quotes. To keep the answers a surprise (not being able to see the answer right below the quote), I will have all of the answers at the bottom of the page.

Keep Reading... Show less
Facebook Comments