books vs movies | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
Entertainment

Real Talk On The 'Movies VS Books' Debate

Books and movies are different formats of storytelling, so, you shouldn't expect the exact same things from both.

1491
Real Talk On The 'Movies VS Books' Debate
Brandy Clymer

Have you ever loved a book, or a book series, then watched the movie for it and were disappointed? Me too. Problem is, after living my whole life this way, I'm starting to realize how unfair I've been.

Now, before you jump down my throat and damn me to Hell over an opinion, let me just explain my reasoning.

Books are written in specific ways and for specific reasons. Okay, valid. The format, the perspective, the internal processing. All important parts of a good book.

Coming back to the format, a book is designed and structured so that readers can dive into the story's reality. Not so different than movies, but the way it's done is. Books require a mixture of flashy parts of excitement, but also dialogue and character perspective that doesn't always lend itself to film.

It's understandable when adaptations are made then, that not everything can be word-for-word from the book.

As long as the filmmakers stay true to the overall story and key parts, small differences between book and movie shouldn't ruin your enjoyment.

At the end of the day, books and movies are different formats of storytelling, so, you shouldn't expect the exact same things from both. Also, why do you want it?

Yes, I say that I would stay and watch a 12-hour long movie so that it would be exactly like the book, but that's not me really enjoying the movie. It may be hard to hear, but wanting movies like that just show an almost lack of creativity/imagination of the audience.

Let's be honest here. Even if you would watch something like that, there isn't enough time for you to watch frequently.

When a book is adapted into a movie, there needs to be a better distinction. Original readers of the books have had access and experience with the story, but moviegoers have not.

If for some reason you can't read the texts, or you're just more of a movie person, you should be able to enjoy the adaptation without the constant critique that is was wrong in this-or-that.

When an author writes, they write to their version of completion. When scriptwriters write, they don't always have that freedom.

Movie adaptations need to find the balance between fan service and stand-alone value.

It'd be great to experience a character's thought process, but not everyone wants a scene with little physical actions and a monologue of sorts. Fans of the books, the movie(s) aren't just for us. Sorry if you weren't prepared for that newsflash.

Sure, there are adaptations that went too far and didn't end up successful or did but added entire storylines, characters, and villains. I'm not saying that all adaptations are made equal. But, I am saying that they are not extensions of the book, as much as they are companions. A new perspective if you will.

At the end-of-the-day, if the story, in either or both formats, made you really feel something, and/or left an impression, it's worth your time and appreciation. You can have your preference in the books versus movies debate, but don't think that your opinion is the only "right" one.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
girl holding phone
NYCPRGIRLS

Now that it seems “talking” is the new way to date, and will stay that way until another idiotic term is used to describe the people who can’t settle down and just date someone, I feel as if it’s time to go over the unwritten rules of “talking.”

Rule 1. Having feeling without feeling.

Keep Reading...Show less
The Stages of Having FOMO in College
iamthatgirl.com

Are you one of those people that gets super upset when you miss out on anything? Well, you may have FOMO, or fear of missing out. In college it’s not hard to experience FOMO every once in a while. You just love doing everything and anything, so hen you have to miss out on something it's the worst possible thing in your mind. Whether you’re sick, have to work, or have so much work to do you could cry – FOMO will hit you hard in college.

Keep Reading...Show less
Vivien Leigh
Revelist

I've lived a whole 21 years with an RBF (Resting Bitch Face), so naturally, I go through most of these struggles on a daily basis.

And before you ask, yes I'm fine. No, I'm not mad. This is just my face, so take it or leave it! To those of you who have been #blessed with an RBF, you'll probably relate to these more than you'd like to:

Keep Reading...Show less
Entertainment

Iconic Duos: Timeless Legends

From Luke and Leia to Beyonce's twins...

774708
Luke and Leia from Star Wars, a iconic duo
Lucasfilm

“Name a more iconic duo... I'll wait." OK, well, if you insist. In no particular order, here's a list of 100 iconic duos that seem to be timeless.

SEE MORE: This Is The ICONIC Disney Sidekick You Are To Your BFF, According To Your Zodiac Sign

Keep Reading...Show less
Relationships

A Candid Letter to My Best Friends Ex

Because this is the real form of torture you deserve.

950
middle finger
Photo by engin akyurt on Unsplash

What's up Asshat,

I've composed a list of things that I wish upon you, and they're harsh and cruel. These things are things that I wouldn't wish upon my worst of enemies, not even that Starbuck's barista who always screws up my order, not even him. You fall into a whole other category of hate. You surpass Starbucks barista. Congratulations, I'm actually a pretty nice person, making you worthy of every single bit of torture I wish upon you. What are these things I wish upon you you might ask?

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments