James Charles, Tati Westbrook Drama,  And Cancel Culture
Start writing a post

The James Charles And Tati Westbrook Drama Reveals The Problems Of Cancel Culture

The subculture itself should probably be cancelled.

The James Charles And Tati Westbrook Drama Reveals The Problems Of Cancel Culture
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9ws6nxMk6I0, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PoVZg4KjRxU

This past week, Youtube beauty guru Tati Westbrook singlehandedly "ended" James Charles' career. Her Youtube video "BYE SISTER" has raked in nearly 50 million views. In the video, Tati publicly called out Charles for endorsing SugarBearHair gummy vitamins, a major competitor to her brand Halo Beauty.

When Westbrook previously asked Charles if he could publicize her brand, he refused on the basis that his subscribers were too young, calling it inappropriate. Westbrook saw his endorsement of SugarBearHair as a massive betrayal.

Although this incident sparked the conflict, there was far more drama included in the 43-minute exposé. Westbrook mentioned Charles' allegedly inappropriate behavior towards straight men, specifically a waiter at a restaurant, coercing them to perform sexual favors for him. She claimed that Charles actively talked behind Westbrook's back and made her friends uncomfortable with sexual comments.

Within minutes of Tati uploading the video, the internet canceled James Charles.

Charles uploaded an apology video called "tati" in response. It has nearly 3 million dislikes, making it the 8th most disliked video on Youtube.

Charles lost subscribers as quickly as Westbrook gained them. Livestreams on Youtube tracked both content creators' subscriber counts. As of now, James Charles has lost over 3 million subscribers and Tati Westbrook has gained over 4 million subscribers.

It's completely valid to unfollow a creator who you find problematic or ill-mannered, as many people did. The aftermath of the drama, however, exposed a different side of online culture.

#JamesCharlesIsOverParty was trending on Twitter, mainly consisting of lighthearted GIFs and memes. Outside of that, many users claimed that James Charles had already "been canceled" due to his actions over the past few years. These "scandals" have included racist jokes about Ebola and transphobic remarks regarding his attraction to trans men. Without hesitation, some users called out the thousands of people who excused said scandals until straight men were included in one.

This is the epitome of "cancel culture", whereas if an influencer acts out or says something highly problematic and oppressive (racist, homophobic, xenophobic, transphobic, sexist, etc.), they will be "canceled" or not given any praise or positive attention in the future. While it's appealing to cancel problematic and oppressive people, there are multiple problems within cancel culture.

First, the grounds to cancel someone are wildly inconsistent. Sometimes the internet decides to cancel people for things they've said anywhere from a year to a decade ago, while some are canceled immediately. Why was James Charles canceled the second Tati's video premiered while Shane Dawson wasn't held accountable until five years after a grossly insensitive pedophilia joke? That's a great deal of time to change, but is it still grounds to cancel?

In cancel culture, there's no clear line between forgiving someone for their actions and dismissing offensive behavior. As soon as one person decides someone is canceled, it seems that everyone does the same, no matter when or how it happened.

This brings us to our next point: the same people get canceled over and over again, which implies they were never actually canceled, to begin with. I'll stick with Shane Dawson as an example. Some of the reasons behind his cancellations include bestiality jokes, blackface, working with Jeffree Star (who was also canceled for racist jokes), and the pedophilia joke.

Though he's been canceled before, his docuseries are immensely popular and have millions of views on Youtube. Shane Dawson gets canceled, forgiven, canceled, and forgiven again. If people were so mad about what he did, why do they keep watching?

Unlike Dawson, Charles had a massive dip in subscriber count, implying that he might actually be canceled this time around. I'll remind you that the difference between this and Charles' past scandals is that this impacts a majority group rather than a minority.

Twitter users pride themselves on their "woke" culture, often hopping on the bandwagon as soon as a "canceled" tag starts trending. This phenomenon calls into question the intentions of cancel culture; whether canceling someone is a performative act more than it is an ethical one.

On 05/16, Tati uploaded a video called "Why I Did It" explaining that she never meant to cause so much hate on the internet.

Two days later on 05/18, James Charles uploaded a video called "No More Lies". He claims that the "straight" waiter was actually bi, emphasizing that their interactions were consensual. Charles also calls Tati Westbrook a liar and claims that she made up his "uncomfortable" sexual comments and betrayal. Furthermore, he released screenshots of text messages between him and Westbrook as well as messages from Jeffree Star, who claimed he was "a danger to society". These messages revealed that multiple other Youtube creators planned on making videos to call out Charles' behavior. Soon after Charles' video premiered, Jeffree Star tweeted this:

Following Charles' upload, Tati is losing subscribers while Charles' fans are deeming her canceled.

It's unclear what Charles' cancel status is We'll see how long that lasts...

And that's the tea, sis.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.

TikTok Made Me Buy It: Flawless's Skincare Fridge

I bought and tested one of TikTok's popular products so you don't have to.


I spend a lot of time on TikTok and I never know whether the products I see are worth it or not, especially when I'm looking at the price. For Christmas, my aunt got me a gift card to Ulta. I didn't know what to buy. I have way too many palettes and lipsticks. I have my essentials. What else could I need? Then it hit me that I saw a lot of people these past few months showing off their skincare fridges. So, the second I thought of it I went on the Ulta app and bought it. So, here are my thoughts.

Keep Reading... Show less

37 Cute And Unique Pinterest Board Titles

Let's be real, the hardest part about Pinterest is thinking of a cute title for your board.


I don't know about anyone else but I have recently become re-obsessed with Pinterest. Like, I am spending a stupid amount of time on Pinterest daily now. While I have been binging Pinterest I have found that I love making cute and aesthetic boards but it is SO hard to come up with a name to match it. So, I scoured the internet and my brain for you. Happy pinning!

Keep Reading... Show less

This Is What Type Of Person You Are Based On Your Favorite Cereal

Your cereal preference reveals more than you think.

Photo by Nyana Stoica on Unsplash

Whether you eat cereal for breakfast or a late-night snack, you probably have a favorite. Little did you know that what you prefer says a lot about your personality.

Keep Reading... Show less
Alexis Hoffman

Due to the COVID-19 pandemic, we all know that cutting out social interaction has taken its toll.

Keep Reading... Show less
Health and Wellness

I Asked Instagram How 2020 Was, And Maybe It Wasn't The Worst Year Ever

2020 is a year to remember but it's not as bad as we made it out to be.


It's finally 2021 and we're honestly all just happy that 2020 is over. I decided to ask my Instagram followers how they felt about 2020 and the results were a little more mixed up than expected.

Keep Reading... Show less

Ever since I watched "How To Lose A Guy In 10 Days," I've been a major Matthew McConaughey fan. I've seen most of his movies, and I definitely got way too excited when he finally made an Instagram! So when he announced he would be releasing a memoir titled "Greenlights," I knew I absolutely had to get my hands on this book. And so did the rest of the world, as the book began to flood social media.

Truthfully, I would much rather read a fiction book and dive into another world than read a nonfiction book - even if it is one of my favorite celebrities. But I had a feeling this book wouldn't disappoint or bore.

Keep Reading... Show less

The Armie Hammer Scandal Discourse Is Kink Shaming And Harming Actual Victims

The rumors surrounding Armie Hammer has resulted in some very toxic and harmful discourse.


Sex is something that occupies a very significant place in our lives. Even asexual people can have an active sex life. With the various types of people that comprise this world, it obviously results in various sexual interests. And unconventional people can engage in some pretty unconventional sex practices. Even the most conventional people on the surface might surprise us with their sexual fantasies.

Keep Reading... Show less
Facebook Comments