I'm A Catholic Woman And I Don't Support Amy Coney Barrett For The Supreme Court
Start writing a post

I'm A Catholic Woman And I Do Not Support Amy Coney Barrett's Nomination To The Supreme Court

Questioning Barrett's beliefs is not anti-Catholic.

I'm A Catholic Woman And I Do Not Support Amy Coney Barrett's Nomination To The Supreme Court

When Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg passed away on September 18, the country barely had time to mourn her passing before discourse around her potential replacement proliferated across the internet.

Ginsburg was a judicial icon, revered for constructing a common law framework that ensured women were equal to men in the eyes of the Constitution. Now a fierce battle is being fought in Washington over who should replace her. All eyes immediately turned to Amy Coney Barrett, a judge for the 7th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. Barrett has been the favorite to fill any vacancy on the Court after being the runner-up to fill Justice Anthony Kennedy's seat, which was ultimately given to Brett Kavanaugh. Barrett is seen as the ideological heir to Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia, the extremely conservative originalist who she clerked for while attending Notre Dame Law School (where she later became a professor).

Amy Coney Barrett's religious views are not traditional to the Catholic Church and are cause for concern.

Barrett is a staunch, religious conservative. In her confirmation hearing for her current judgeship, Barrett was questioned about her involvement with a group called "People of Praise," a conservative Catholic group created as a reaction to the new, less restrictive rules created by the Church during the Second Vatican Council. According to the New York Times, "The group believes in prophecy, speaking in tongues, and divine healings." Former members have likened it to a "cult."

A former Notre Dame professor who left People of Praise characterized some of its teachings about women: "According to a teaching that has been circulating among the community heads, women are by nature manipulative." In the community, people are required to report to community heads which they are supposed to consult for almost every decision they make. For married women, their spiritual heads are their husbands. Women are not allowed to have high-level leadership positions in the community although there are some "women leaders," which were until very recently known as "handmaids." I find all these teachings inconsistent with the official Catholic doctrine as laid out in the Catechism.

Still, my major concern with Amy Coney Barrett is not that she is religious, it is that we do not know what beliefs or covenants she is bound to and how they influence her judicial decisionmaking.

At Notre Dame Law School's 2006 Commencement ceremony, Barrett said a "legal career is but a means to an end, and... that end is building the kingdom of God." There are valid questions about what bearing Barrett's faith has on her legal interpretations of access to contraception, LGBTQ rights, women's rights, and most pressingly, abortion. Since the People of Praise strays from the teachings of the Church, it is unclear what views she holds on these issues from both a personal and legal perspective. This only becomes more concerning when taken in conjunction with her disrespect for precedence.

Barrett has previously written about her originalist interpretation of the Constitution. Barrett once wrote: "There is little reason to think that reversals [of past decisions] would do much damage" to the Supreme Court's reputation. "I tend to agree with those who say that a justice's duty is to the Constitution." Her unclear commitment to the legal doctrine known as stare decisis, which asserts that Supreme Court precedents should be respected, is ripe for scrutinization. With Ginsburg gone, Roe v. Wade is closer to being overturned than it ever has before and Barrett's appointment could make it a reality. It is of supreme importance that the connection between Barrett's religious views and judicial interpretations be understood clearly as it relates to a contentious issue like abortion. Will she respect stare decisis or be guided by her pro-life position when deciding a case that challenges Roe? These are questions of paramount importance.

There is nothing wrong with a Justice being religious but they have a duty to the American people and the Senate to disclose the ways in which their judicial doctrine is affected by their religious dogma, especially when it deviates from traditional Church teachings.

Report this Content

Where To Find The Best Coffee Drinks In America, According To A Survey

Here's the coffee shop where you should get your morning brew.


Coffee, for billions of people, is one of the only things that can get us out of bed (after hitting snooze a time or two), especially in 2020. Because, if we're being honest, is there anything that beats a quality cup of coffee on those mornings when all we wanted to do is roll over and go back to sleep? The answer is no. And if you're headed to a coffee shop to pick up your caffeinated beverage, you don't want to sleep on the best coffee drinks in America.

According to LiveShopper Sassie's Coffee Project survey, when it comes to chain coffee shops, there are definitely preferred spots you'll want to hit up for your go-to order — whether you order the classic, frozen, or flavored coffee, an espresso, tea, or other. To figure out the hot spots, 1,000 coffee drinkers across the United States took to LiveShopper's mobile app, PrestoShopper, to answer various questions about their coffee drinking habits and preferences. In return, these survey respondents got money back for their coffee — something any user who downloads the app can do as well (yes, even you).

Keep Reading... Show less
Content Inspiration

Survey: Which Issues Are The Most Important To You In The 2020 Election

If you're a first-time voter or voting by mail for the first time, we want to hear your story.


The general election on Tuesday, November 3, 2020, will decide not only the next president of the United States but also which political party controls the House of Representatives and the Senate. Young and first-time voters will play a crucial part in determining the result.

Keep Reading... Show less

I Live In Ohio And I Haven't Received My Mail-In Ballot Yet — And I'm Not The Only One

Delays in absentee ballots have made left Ohioans unsure when or if they're going to receive their ballots.


Like over a million Ohioans, I requested an absentee ballot for the November election. And like thousands of Ohioans, I don't know when — or if — I'll get that ballot.

Keep Reading... Show less

Articles To Write If You're All About Saving More Money, And Waking Up A Little Bit Earlier

Get your day started right — and keep that budget tight.


For all the young professionals, parents, and students out there who've been working, learning, or even teaching remote — 2020 has likely been the longest year of your life. If you didn't know (sorry), we've been locked down for over 200 days now, and chances are, you are ready for it to be OVER.

Keep Reading... Show less

Birth Control Doesn't 'Induce Abortion,' Ted Cruz, — That's Not Politics, That's Science

No one is out here attacking the male condom, so leave birth control pills and other contraceptive methods that prevent pregnancy alone.


Forget politics or religion, this is legitimate healthcare, this is sexual health education, this is freedom.

Keep Reading... Show less

How Much Of A Coffee Snob You Are, Based On Where You Live

Your state may determine how picky you are about your coffee.


When it comes to coffee, everyone has different criteria for what goes into their "perfect cup." Some caffeine lovers, though, are extra particular when it comes to their beloved beverage. One survey found that the state you're from (or the one you live in now) may play a part in determining how much of a coffee snob you actually are.

LiveShopper Sassie, the company behind this Coffee Project survey, received input from 1,000 coffee drinkers via their mobile app, PrestoShopper, to ask various questions about their coffee drinking habits and preferences. In return, these survey respondents got money back for their coffee — something any user who downloads the app can do as well (yes, even you).

Keep Reading... Show less

Encountering homeless individuals while going to class or getting groceries is not a rare occurrence here in Honolulu, Hawaii. In fact, it would be rarer to experience the latter. I have personally never left the bubble of campus and not had a notable encounter with at least one homeless person during that given trip.

Keep Reading... Show less

Amy Coney Barrett Said Sexuality Is A Choice By Saying 'Sexual Preferences' — But It's Not

Judge Amy Coney Barrett used a term that many feel implies sexuality is a choice.


When Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg passed away in September, we lost a remarkable woman who was at the forefront of progressive values. She not only stood up for women, but she supported the LGBTQ community. RBG was the first Supreme Court member to officiate a same-sex marriage ceremony. Her backing the LGBTQ community meant so much to us. It helped push us towards the progress we see today.

Keep Reading... Show less

Don't Be Fooled By Mike Pence, He's The Same As Trump — But With An Indoor Voice

The vice president presents the same views as the president but with an indoor voice. To me, that's scary.


The vice presidential debate between Vice President Mike Pence and Senator Kamala Harris was markedly different from the first presidential debate. I'm far from the first person to note that it seemed almost tame in comparison.

Keep Reading... Show less
Student Life

Everything You Need To Know To Write About COVID-19 On Your College Campus

We want to hear what your university is doing about COVID-19.


Going to college is stressful enough, but going to college in the time of coronavirus (COVID-19) is more stressful than ever. You're not just trying to pass classes or get that cute guy a couple of desks down to notice you, you're trying to avoid a virus! With this in mind, every university has different precautions set to help their students have a safe school year.

Keep Reading... Show less

Thankfully most of us are fully aware when a guy is mansplaining something to you. In case you don't know what mansplaining is, the Merriam-Webster Dictionary defines it as "explaining something to a woman in a condescending way that assumes she has no knowledge about the topic."

In any case, Kamala Harris made us all very proud during the vice presidential debate when Mike Pence was spewing gibberish while she was eloquently speaking. Kamala replied to Mike's disrespectful interruptions with a simple "I'm speaking," and honestly, we should take notes.

Keep Reading... Show less

As a student, semesters can be challenging even when schools are operating normally. Now the coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic is impacting colleges, universities, and their students in completely unique ways.

Keep Reading... Show less
Facebook Comments