Netflix Cuts ‘Thirteen Reasons Why’ Scene
Start writing a post

Congrats To Netflix For It Taking 3 YEARS To Remove Hannah's Graphic Suicide Scene On '13 Reasons Why'

Young peoples' lives deserve more than a three-year-late apology.

‘Thirteen Reasons Why’

Nearly two and a half years following its release, Netflix series "Thirteen Reasons Why" remains one of the most controversial shows to make the rounds in quite some time.

The debate over how much is too much to show and say has loads of passionate folks on both sides, despite the fact that most experts have said from the beginning that there are certain ways suicide should be talked about and shown (or more accurately not shown) in media.

Much to my disappointment, the series has been renewed for a third season which is set to premiere later this year. However, this week the show made headlines for a new reason: in a historic first for Netflix, the company has revealed that they will be editing the first season and cutting out the scene that shows Hannah Baker graphically dying by suicide.

Netflix disclosed the change by saying, "On the advice of medical experts, including Dr. Christine Moutier, Chief Medical Officer at the American Foundation for Suicide Prevention, we've decided ... to edit the scene in which Hannah takes her own life from Season 1."

The advice, of course, is not new. It has been widely accepted in the mental health community for years now that there are very specific safety measures media should take when discussing suicide, including not focusing on means, using language like "died by suicide" instead of "committed suicide," and certainly not showing a suicide under any circumstances, especially one as graphic as the one in "Thirteen Reasons Why."

The blatantly ignored warnings have had heartbreakingly tangible consequences. Suicide hotlines saw a dramatic increase in calls citing the scene as an immediate trigger and Internet searches for ways to die by suicide increased 26% following the show's release.

Even more troubling is the finding from the Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry that the show was associated with a 28.9% increase in suicide rates among U.S. youth ages 10-17 in the month (April 2017) following the show's release.

The number of deaths by suicide recorded in this month was greater than the number seen in any single month during the five-year period examined by the researchers. These statistics make it painfully clear that the graphic scene, and arguably the show in its entirety, has done far more harm than good.

Netflix's decision to edit out the scene in question is a responsible decision. But it's hard to be too proud given the damage that has already been done. Some of it irreversible.

We as a society need to be much more careful and hold ourselves much more accountable to how we handle issues like suicide, both in media and in our everyday lives. We need to keep talking about it. But we need to do it at the advisement of experts in the field and listen when young people say a show is making them think about killing themselves.

Young peoples' lives deserve more than a three-year-late apology. And frankly, it's embarrassing that it's taking us this long to realize that.

Report this Content

How Technology Has Changed Our Lives

While we are all very dependant on technology, we are losing touch with humanity.

How Technology Has Changed Our Lives

If we look back on how our ancestors lived we can sense a totally different lifestyle. If they could come back and live with all our technological devices they surely would think they are in a completely new alien world. They lived such a simple life without our devices that it seems as if centuries have passed by. In reality most of the discoveries were accomplished in the past twenty years. Indeed we have assisted a total technological distortion. This change in our lives was characterized by a myriad of technological innovations, due to globalization.

Keep Reading...Show less

Why I Love Football

Why Is Football A Sport That Is So Celebrated Across The Nation?

College quarterback drops back to make pass as football season begins

It is the time of year when the athletic event of football tends to exhilarate fans across the Nation. Why is football a sport that is so celebrated across the Nation? Many times I have asked myself why I even love the game of football so much, especially being a female, but I came up with a few of the many reasons why football fans love the game. though this may not be everyone's reasons for loving the game, here are some reasons that I love football.

Keep Reading...Show less

Nostalgic Early 2000s Barbies: 34 Forgotten Treasures

For all the 90's babies and their obsession with Barbies.

Barbies on a display case

With Barbie mania overtaking society with the release of the new movie, here is some late 90's/early 2000's nostalgia for you in Barbie form.

It's sure to stir up old memories and unlock some good ones. And if you're feeling inspired by a particular toy but you don't remember where you put it, we've listed where you can find one today. You're welcome.

Keep Reading...Show less

Riots and Protests rock Paris and other French cities

Crazy European Summer

Riots and Protests rock Paris and other French cities
A 17 year old boy of North African origin was shot and killed by French police during a traffic stop on Tuesday. The police claimed they "feared for their lives" when the boy started driving away from them and opened fire, killing him.
Keep Reading...Show less

When DEI goes haywire

Shocking Revelation: Doctors Resort to Ethnicity-Based Prioritization in Medical Care

When DEI goes haywire
In a shocking move in New Zealand, surgeons must now consider ethnicity in prioritizing patients for operations.
Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments