Why The New American Girl Doll Is Controversial | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
Politics and Activism

Why The New American Girl Doll Is Controversial

1082
Why The New American Girl Doll Is Controversial

American girl has just released it's third African American doll. She goes by the name of Melody Ellison, and she's from civil rights era Detroit, Michigan. She is the first African American doll since 2011's Cecile Rey, who was discontinued in 2014. The doll was released just in time for the company's 30th anniversary as well as in celebration of Black History month.

Every American Girl doll comes with a unique backstory, told in a series of short children's books. Melody is introduced as a 9-year-old girl who is beginning to learn about the Civil Rights Movement and is forming her views on equality. Her story is supposed to speak to the fight for equality and the racial tensions of the era.

The company's new doll has been getting criticized for not accurately representing the African American culture and true African American experiences. The doll's physical characteristics have also been questioned because she has a lighter skin complexion with long straight hair and European facial features. Even though American girl has had three African American dolls, none have been dark skinned or shown African facial features.This is not the first time that American Girl has received criticism for it's lack of diversity among their dolls. Out of about ten American Girl "Be Forever" dolls, the two that happened to be discontinued were minorities; African American Cecile Rey and Chinese American Ivy Ling.

On the flip side, some argue that the doll does accurately represent African Americans of that time period. Her outfit, for example, is historically accurate because African Americans of the period where known for going out in their Sunday best majority of the time. This was to avoid negative racial characterizations. Melody's story is also still being developed, so there is plenty of time for her path to, overtime, clearly play out and represent African American girls and their stories. It is hoped that her story will include details about the Great Migration and the racial tensions that spurred white flight.

American girl dolls predominately follow the stories of Caucasian girls, but many online sources think that the company should do more to share stories from all walks of life. The Melody doll is a good step in that direction, that is if they continue you to develop her in a way that is authentic and true to the stories of real African American girls, past and present.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
Health and Wellness

To The Cheerful Person On Their Rainy Days, You Are Valid

The world is not always sunshine and rainbows, and you do not have to be, either.

117
pug covered with blanket on bedspread
Photo by Matthew Henry on Unsplash

Ask friends of mine to name a quality about me, and one a lot them will point out the fact that I am almost always smiling. I like to laugh and smile -- not to quote Buddy the Elf in April, but smiling is my favorite! It is probably my favorite go-to expression. However, what a lot of people do not see is that I have my down days. I have days when smiling and laughing is a real struggle, or when I have so much on my plate that going out of my way to behappy takes more effort than I have stored in me. Be it a symptom of college and growing up or a facet of life, I cannot always be content.

Keep Reading...Show less
Student Life

11 Struggles of Packing for College

It would be so much easier to just pay someone to do it for you

180
a room with boxes and a window

1. Figuring out when to start

Timing is key, you don’t want to start too early or too late.

Keep Reading...Show less
Entertainment

15 Times 'Parks and Recreation' Has Summed Up Your Life

Relatable moments from one of the best shows I have ever watched.

158
parks and rec
Liz Keysmash

Amidst my hectic college career, I always find time for one thing, even on the busiest weeks: Parks and Recreation. This show has made me laugh and has made me cry, but most of all I have related to this show more than I would like to admit.

Here are some "Parks and Rec" moments that relate to life struggles that just about everyone faces.

Keep Reading...Show less
April Ludgate
Facebook

April Ludgate from Parks and Recreation is notorious for her "I don't care" attitude. She speaks her mind without caring what anyone thinks of her. Fans love her because she isn't afraid to be herself. April can seem cold and negative, but she's really just fearless and strong-minded. And despite her sometimes harsh words, April truly cares about the people she's closest to. These are all reasons she is the epitome of a college student. April complains whenever she has to do any kind of work, but ends up doing the work anyway. April Ludgate is the ultimate college student spirit animal.

Keep Reading...Show less
Adulting

11 Ways To Live The Best Life You Can

Life is full of twists and turns, but you have to keep going.

16
girl bike

Life is all about twist and turns, sideways and which ways. Nothing is permanent, so we should take risks, and chase our dreams. We are taught at a young age many lessons that will follow us into adulthood. What we aren't taught is how to feel, and how we handle those emotions. We just have to figure them out ourselves, and that's not fun. In my 21 years of living, I have come to know that way too many people can't handle emotions, or the fact that not everyone is dead inside like them. When you're like me, and you have zero control over your emotions, it's hard to feel comfortable around people who aren't so in touch with themselves. As much as I would like to feel nothing at times, I've accepted who I am and the fact that I can cry over practically nothing. So, there are some things in life that you just have to do.

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments