Dear America, Stop Pretending You Know A Person's Health Just By Looking At Them
Start writing a post
Health and Wellness

Dear America, Stop Pretending You Know A Person's Health Just By Looking At Them

You absolutely cannot tell another person's health by their appearances.

3041
Dear America, Stop Pretending You Know A Person's Health Just By Looking At Them
@modcloth

Last week I got a message from a private client asking me to essentially help her "diet without dieting". She said her doctor is concerned about her blood pressure and how quickly she has gained weight.

By now you all know that I am against dieting, so how am I supposed to handle situations like this? Is dieting acceptable if it's "for health"? Is there a way to even "diet without dieting"?

Before I can answer these questions, I need to break a common misconception:

Weight and health are not inextricably linked.

An above-average weight does not equate to bad health, and you are not ensured good health just because you have a socially acceptable relationship between gravity and the earth. The "obesity epidemic" itself is a myth; it is socially constructed according to society's ideas of a "good" body, and it deeply affects our understandings of weight and health.

Obesity correlates with bad health, yes. But it does not cause bad health. Overall, weight and BMIs are very poor indicators of health. Things like blood pressure and the degree to which one's life is sedentary or active are much better indicators. You can be skinny with an unhealthy blood pressure, and you can be fat with a healthy, active lifestyle.

We know this, scientifically, yet we have trouble accepting it because our culture tells us otherwise.

Next time you see health/fitness/diet industries and politicians waving around statistics about the impending social and economic dangers of obesity, I urge you to see them critically. I am a very active individual, an athlete and performer, and a vegetarian. But I am overweight, according to BMI standards. Athletes like myself often reveal a fatal flaw of the BMI system (as we tend to weigh more due to muscle), yet this is the system by which all those obesity statistics are calculated. Next time you read "60% of American adults are overweight or obese", remember that I'm included in that category.

The fact that fit people are included in obesity statistics is not the only thing wrong with our current system, though. The real problem is that healthy people, thin or not, are included in the very statistics that try to show us how unhealthy we are. That's because these stats are based on weight and height even though size does not dictate health.

For the sake of all that is good and holy, please understand this: You absolutely cannot tell a person's health by their appearances. It simply is not possible. Contrary to societal belief, there are plenty of unhealthy skinny people and healthy fat people walking this earth as we speak. So we must separate weight from health.

We must decouple aesthetics from health. Period.

You have been raised to connect "health" to "thin" and "thin" to "pretty", but these are only false binaries. The problem with these social constructions of weight, health, and beauty is that they produce real consequences: If we're being honest, we're all either living in terror of being fat or we're actually fat and living in stigma. And we justify this absurd behavior by claiming concern for "health", even though size does not determine health, whatsoever. And that's why diets exist. But diets don't work, and I hope you choose a healthier, safer, more effective, and more sustainable way to secure your health.


So to answer the previous questions posed by my client: no, dieting is not the answer, not even "for health".

Since as a culture we've come to equate health with thinness, dieting is inevitably motivated by weight loss. The ultimate goal of any diet is to change one's body, despite the fact that there is no scientifically proven way for dieting and weight loss to be effective long-term.

We must break the common misconception that not dieting means that you don't care about your health. In today's world, dieting is what we believe we do to get healthy, so it's so hard to get rid of that mentality. We believe we have to either diet or we're "letting ourselves go"-- it's yet another false binary, to be honest. In reality, you aren't letting yourself go if you give up dieting. You're simply letting yourself be (controversial, I know).

But before you go discounting me, check out Linda Bacon, Ph.D, the woman who developed the Health At Every Size (HAES) approach in order to challenge weight myths and help women find true health (like physically, mentally, and emotionally). Simply put, HAES is the truth that you can be healthy no matter what body you're in; i.e., you can take care of yourself healthfully at every size.

So, then, what do you do if you want to get healthier but dieting is not the answer? What are people, like my client, supposed to do when weight-related problems seem to threaten their health?

In the spirit of anti-diet nutrition, I referred my client to this (last week's) article of mine. I refuse to recommend dieting because, with current scientific knowledge, it's no longer ethical for doctors, nutrition, and diet professionals to recommend weight loss because weight and health are much more independent than was previously thought.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
Olivia White

"The American flag does not fly because the wind moves it. It flies from the last breath of each solider who died protecting it."

Keep Reading... Show less
Featured

Separation Anxiety in Pets

Separation anxiety in pets is a real thing and recognizing the warning signs is important.

231771

Since March, Covid-19 required most of the world to quarantine in their homes. Majority of people ended up working from home for nearly five months. This meant pet owners were constantly with their pets giving them attention, playing with them, letting them out etc. Therefore, when the world slowly started to open up again and pet owners began returning to normal life work schedules away from the home, pet owners noticed a difference in the way their pet acted. Many pets develop separation anxiety especially during this crazy time when majority people were stuck inside barely leaving the house.

Keep Reading... Show less
Featured

The invention of photography

The history of photography is the recount of inventions, scientific discoveries and technical improvements that allowed human beings to capture an image on a photosensitive surface for the first time, using light and certain chemical elements that react with it.

373305

The history of photography is the recount of inventions, scientific discoveries and technical improvements that allowed human beings to capture an image on a photosensitive surface for the first time, using light and certain chemical elements that react with it.

Keep Reading... Show less
Health and Wellness

Exposing Kids To Nature Is The Best Way To Get Their Creative Juices Flowing

Constantly introducing young children to the magical works of nature will further increase the willingness to engage in playful activities as well as broaden their interactions with their peers

1768409

Whenever you are feeling low and anxious, just simply GO OUTSIDE and embrace nature! According to a new research study published in Frontiers in Psychology, being connected to nature and physically touching animals and flowers enable children to be happier and altruistic in nature. Not only does nature exert a bountiful force on adults, but it also serves as a therapeutic antidote to children, especially during their developmental years.

Keep Reading... Show less
Facebook Comments