Republicans, Your Tobacco Restrictions Are Hypocritical
Start writing a post
Currently

Dear Republicans, Your Tobacco Restrictions Are Hypocritical When You Deregulate Other Industries

Trump's latest tobacco sales restriction highlights a gap in the Republican value of small government.

191
Dear Republicans, Your Tobacco Restrictions Are Hypocritical When You Deregulate Other Industries

On December 20, President Trump signed a $1.4 trillion spending plan that is meant to fund the federal government through September 30 of next year. Attached to this plan was a provision that would raise the legal age to purchase tobacco products from 18 to 21. Trump, who expressed support for raising this age limit as early as September, lauded this achievement via Twitter, describing the new restriction simply as "BIG!"

This restriction is backed by senators from both sides of the political aisle and has been described by CNN as a "major public health achievement" for the White House. There's no denying that youth tobacco use is still an issue, especially with the recent increase in cases of vaping-related lung damage. It's clear that the provision is well-intentioned.

But coming from the party that so loudly denounces big government with regards to issues like gun control and environmental regulation (also major public welfare issues), this restriction on the sale of tobacco products is nothing short of hypocritical.

When we shift the topic from tobacco to something more hot-button, like gun control, Republicans quickly alter their stance on the efficiency of such restrictions. Trump himself has described gun and magazine bans as "a total failure," wielding the infamous argument that no matter what restrictions you impose upon law-abiding citizens, some people will inevitably "slip through the cracks."

So why is tobacco any different?

A three-year age increase likely won't stop current smokers (regardless of age) from purchasing tobacco products, and the current use of tobacco products by people under 18 makes it clear that there are already ways to slip through the cracks and attain tobacco. If Republicans are so intent on "[reducing] the size of government" (again, straight from Trump), then it makes very little sense for them to support a provision that inserts the government directly into the personal lives and habits of their constituents.

After all, a person with a gun can kill dozens of people. A person with a cigarette can only kill themself.

This is not to say that tobacco restrictions are a bad idea. This is not even to say that the provision will be entirely ineffective because if it can manage to stop even a few young adults from becoming lifelong smokers, it will indeed be a significant achievement for public health.

This comparison is primarily meant to emphasize the hypocrisy of the Republican Party when it comes to government involvement. On a topic so fundamental to our core American values, it makes no sense for the party to condemn government interference on topics of their choice while simultaneously celebrating the benefits that can come from such involvement. If Republican leaders can argue that legislation aimed at reducing tobacco sales will be effective but can't make the same argument when it comes to guns, a clear gap in their reasoning is exposed.

When it comes to public health and safety, the government either has a place in the lives of the people, or it doesn't. The party that currently leads America shouldn't get to pick and choose which one at its convenience.

Report this Content
Featured

How Technology Has Changed Our Lives

While we are all very dependant on technology, we are losing touch with humanity.

2392
How Technology Has Changed Our Lives

If we look back on how our ancestors lived we can sense a totally different lifestyle. If they could come back and live with all our technological devices they surely would think they are in a completely new alien world. They lived such a simple life without our devices that it seems as if centuries have passed by. In reality most of the discoveries were accomplished in the past twenty years. Indeed we have assisted a total technological distortion. This change in our lives was characterized by a myriad of technological innovations, due to globalization.

Keep Reading...Show less
Sports

Why I Love Football

Why Is Football A Sport That Is So Celebrated Across The Nation?

5575
College quarterback drops back to make pass as football season begins
https://pixabay.com/en/quarterback-american-football-sport-67701/

It is the time of year when the athletic event of football tends to exhilarate fans across the Nation. Why is football a sport that is so celebrated across the Nation? Many times I have asked myself why I even love the game of football so much, especially being a female, but I came up with a few of the many reasons why football fans love the game. though this may not be everyone's reasons for loving the game, here are some reasons that I love football.

Keep Reading...Show less
Student Life

Nostalgic Early 2000s Barbies: 34 Forgotten Treasures

For all the 90's babies and their obsession with Barbies.

29578
Barbies on a display case
LATimes

With Barbie mania overtaking society with the release of the new movie, here is some late 90's/early 2000's nostalgia for you in Barbie form.

It's sure to stir up old memories and unlock some good ones. And if you're feeling inspired by a particular toy but you don't remember where you put it, we've listed where you can find one today. You're welcome.

Keep Reading...Show less
Featured

Riots and Protests rock Paris and other French cities

Crazy European Summer

1239
Riots and Protests rock Paris and other French cities
A 17 year old boy of North African origin was shot and killed by French police during a traffic stop on Tuesday. The police claimed they "feared for their lives" when the boy started driving away from them and opened fire, killing him.
Keep Reading...Show less
Featured

When DEI goes haywire

Shocking Revelation: Doctors Resort to Ethnicity-Based Prioritization in Medical Care

1451
When DEI goes haywire
In a shocking move in New Zealand, surgeons must now consider ethnicity in prioritizing patients for operations.
Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments