The theory started from a Brazilian fan blog where it first stated that after Lavigne's album "Let it Go" in 2002, Lavigne went from being this emo punk girl to a mainstream pop girl. From here is when the theory that she died started because many fans thought she started to downfall from her fame so much that she hired a look-alike to take her place in front of paparazzi.
Later, her grandfather passed away and instead of announcing her death her record label decided to continue making money and use Melissa as a replacement. Below are a few of the differences that many fans noticed which sparked the conspiracy theory even more. Lavigne released "The Best Damn Thing" album in 2007 and fans noticed differences in the handwriting, eye shape, punctuation, word use, and even freckles.
Then there's the idea that the eye shape is completely different, which honestly does look a little weird.
Fans get mixed signals from even terminology that Avril would supposedly never use.
Many fans noticed the difference in freckles and how Avril on the right has a lot less than "Melissa" on the left.
Lastly, song lyrics that seems to reveal that Melissa had taken over.
Avril Lavigne has spoken out about how none of this is true and she has no clue why it would even be thought up, but will anyone ever know? What do you think?
