A few weeks ago, I was having a conversation with a friend about Chris Brown's tour. He asked me if I was planning on attending his concert to which I replied something along the lines of, "Excuse me?" followed by an, "I really don't think you want to have this conversation with me."
As much as I've tried to knock it, I can't stop thinking about the discussion we had that night. Really, I can't stop thinking about all the news that has been surrounding celebrities and violence of all kinds.
Each time I check my social media or watch the news I find myself unbelievably heartbroken, disappointed and plain furious. With the rise of the "Me Too" movement, it seems that all of the skeletons are being let out of the closet.
Other than Chris Brown, I found myself especially devastated about the allegations against one of my favorite (former?) artists, Melanie Martinez.
I think I found myself especially betrayed because I thought that as a woman, she would "know better" than anybody the impact sexual assault can have on a person's life. Almost immediately, I removed all of her songs from my playlists.
Now, if one of her songs happens to come on I am struck with unparalleled confusion. If I'm driving and "Kiss Kiss" by Chris Brown comes on I can't help but want to sing along.
In both of these cases, the artist has made a claim for themselves. Honestly, none of us will ever know the truth. All I know is that at some point their music has spoken to me in a very special way.
So, the question that I have for all of you is, can we separate the art from the artist?
The difficult thing is that I study these topics all day in my classes. Because of that, I have formed pretty strong opinions about most everything in life. Yet, this specific issue has left me torn. I find myself spiraling into a stream of thought that undoubtedly leads to question after question.
I can't stop asking:
Does supporting their work poorly reflect my character?
I think at this point, I have made it fairly clear that I'm a "crazy feminist". As a feminist, I believe it would send the wrong message to others if I openly listened to Chris Brown or Melanie Martinez. If I support their music, can I even call myself a feminist?
Even if I ignore the judgment of others, that doesn't mean that I wouldn't think poorly of myself anyway. By being their fan, am I invalidating or erasing the story these women have told?
Aren't their actions a product of society?
But then I take a step back. I remind myself that yes, people do awful things, but they do these things for a reason. These artists are human, just as we are. The only difference is that a magnifying glass is constantly held to them. Can we truly blame the individual for the story that society has told them about what is and isn't acceptable?
Rape culture is very real. Chris Brown found fame at what, age fourteen or fifteen? Take this extremely talented boy and introduce him to adoring fans and complete access to whatever drugs, alcohol, and women he wants. How is he supposed to respond?
This isn't to say that hitting a woman should be excused, but can you imagine what that amount of power can do to a child?
Like I said before, I clearly don't have any answers. Honestly, the further I get into this article I get, the more conflicted I feel. And maybe, to others' music is just music. For me, it oozes from my soul and blends each sense to perfection. When something means everything to you, it is hard not to care.
Now, I'm not even sure there is a correct answer. By all means, if you have any thoughts, please share them with me.