How Judge Reeves Saved Religious Liberty | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
Lifestyle

How Judge Reeves Saved Religious Liberty

Christian leaders fought a bill supposedly crafted to protect them.

17
How Judge Reeves Saved Religious Liberty
Brandiilyne Dear

Last April, Mississippi Gov. Phil Bryant signed HB 1523 into law. Starting July 1, this law would have allowed landlords to evict gay and trans renters, employers to fire workers for being LGBT, private businesses to refuse service to LGBT people, given doctors a right to refuse to treat them, and permitted clerks to refuse to marry them.

At the midnight hour, Reeves issued an injunction to stop the law from taking effect.

Although Bryant argued that its law promoted religious liberty, Reeves stated that HB 1523 actually “establishes an official preference for certain religious beliefs over others,” thus violating the Establishment Clause. Adherents to anti-LGBT religious beliefs receive a special right to discriminate over others.

For example, as Reeves points out, "HB 1523 favors Southern Baptist over Unitarian doctrine, Catholic over Episcopalian doctrine, and Orthodox Judaism over Reform Judaism doctrine, to list just a few examples."

Several case plaintiffs included religious leaders such Rims Barber (of Barber v. Bryant) and Carol Burnett, who are ordained Christian ministers; retired Millsaps chaplain and ordained minister Don Fortenberry; the Joshua Generation Metropolitan Community Church in Hattiesburg, its pastor Brandiilyne Magnum-Dear, and director of worship Susan Magnum.

“Persons who hold contrary religious beliefs are unprotected,” Reeves explains. Thus, “the State has put its thumb on the scale to favor some religious beliefs over others...at the expense of other citizens.”

Defenders of the bill claimed that it would protect religious organizations from punishment if they refused to solemnize a same-sex marriage, but "religious organizations already have that right under the Free Exercise Clause of the First Amendment."

By uniquely burdening a certain community, Reeves notes, HB 1523 also violates the Equal Protection Clause of the 14th Amendment. Under the Supreme Court’s decision in Romer v. Evans, laws motivated by “animus”, or hostility, toward minorities are unconstitutional.

If Mississippi legislatures hadn’t been so blunt about their animus towards a specific minority, they might have had more plausible deniability. But the speaker of the House stated that Obergefell was “in direct conflict with God’s design for marriage as set forth in the Bible” and announced, “I don’t care what the Supreme Court says.” Other representatives called HB 1523 “very specific to LGBT people” and “balancing legislation to Obergefell.”

Clearly, as Reeves noted, supporters unabashedly “indicate that the bill was the State’s attempt to put LGBT citizens back in their place after Obergefell.”

This was, after all, the legislature’s own words.

Gov. Bryant has already vowed to spend more of the poorest state’s taxpayer money to fight this ruling.

But the presence of religious leaders among the plaintiffs challenging HB 1523, combined with Reeves’ comprehensive opinion, demonstrated that neither America’s religious leaders nor its Constitution tolerate discrimination against minorities by favoring one religion over another.
Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
12 Things To Do On A Snow Day

Everyone loves a snow day! Whether you decide to call out sick from work or your classes get canceled, it is a great way to spend time with family and friends.

1. Build a snowman

People brave enough to face the weather can go outside to build an adorable man made of snow. Relive those childhood glory days, but remember to bundle up!

Keep Reading...Show less
April Ludgate
NBC Universal

Everyone who is in college right now, or has ever been, knows the struggle of pulling in the strings at the last second. It seems impossible, and you have to do a LOT of things in order to assure your future for the next semester.

April Ludgate, historically, is a very annoyed person, and she doesn't hide it. Of all the times that I binged and re-binged "Parks and Rec," her attitude relates more and more to me.

Keep Reading...Show less
Health and Wellness

To The Cheerful Person On Their Rainy Days, You Are Valid

The world is not always sunshine and rainbows, and you do not have to be, either.

806
pug covered with blanket on bedspread
Photo by Matthew Henry on Unsplash

Ask friends of mine to name a quality about me, and one a lot them will point out the fact that I am almost always smiling. I like to laugh and smile -- not to quote Buddy the Elf in April, but smiling is my favorite! It is probably my favorite go-to expression. However, what a lot of people do not see is that I have my down days. I have days when smiling and laughing is a real struggle, or when I have so much on my plate that going out of my way to behappy takes more effort than I have stored in me. Be it a symptom of college and growing up or a facet of life, I cannot always be content.

Keep Reading...Show less
Student Life

11 Struggles of Packing for College

It would be so much easier to just pay someone to do it for you

805
a room with boxes and a window

1. Figuring out when to start

Timing is key, you don’t want to start too early or too late.

Keep Reading...Show less
Entertainment

15 Times 'Parks and Recreation' Has Summed Up Your Life

Relatable moments from one of the best shows I have ever watched.

586
parks and rec
Liz Keysmash

Amidst my hectic college career, I always find time for one thing, even on the busiest weeks: Parks and Recreation. This show has made me laugh and has made me cry, but most of all I have related to this show more than I would like to admit.

Here are some "Parks and Rec" moments that relate to life struggles that just about everyone faces.

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments