I'm Christian And No, 'God in Schools' Will NOT Work

I'm Christian And No, 'God in Schools' Will NOT Work

The tired argument and why it doesn't work.

About a week ago, another mass shooting occurred, this time in Florida. Before I begin, I want to express my sorrow and sympathy that lies with not only the victims but with their friends and families as well. Tragedy, heartbreak, and sadness gripped the nation and still does. Various solutions were proposed; gun control, mental health reform, and so on. There was one proposal, however, that grinds my gears still; "let God back into schools."

The argument is simple; since the Supreme Court decisions regarding prayer, God, and the Ten Commandments, we have (supposedly) observed increases in crime, violence, so on and so forth. This is oftentimes interpreted as God being "angry" with us, and can only be corrected by introducing God and mandatory prayer into schools, thus improving society. While this may seem like quite the "easy" argument, it is one easily discredited.

For one, crime has been trending downwards for the past two decades. FBI and the Bureau of Justice Statistics data shows sharp declines in crime. Crime spikes can easily be attributed to other factors, as well, such as the drug trade of the '80s and so on. What would introducing God into the classroom do to that? Nothing. Furthermore, America has become far more secular. Does that correlation mean that removing God from the classroom HAS worked? No.

The most deadly massacre of school children occurred in 1927, the Bath school bombings, and God was considered part of school then. This isn't even a purely American phenomenon; multiple societies that are far less religious than ours have also seen a decrease in crime over the past two decades. Is that the product of God being removed from schools? It works both ways, and it's a bad argument.

Second, which God? Oftentimes, this is coupled with the idea of the Ten Commandments and "school prayer." But oftentimes, this is promoting one God; the Christian God. I'm Catholic, but there are other students of other religions at my school, and have been throughout the years. Jewish students, Muslims, Hindu, even a few Buddhist students.

What would introducing a God do to the other students besides alienate them? Oftentimes, this is "refuted" by saying we should introduce all the religions into the classroom, but that's not introducing GOD, that's introducing religion. Furthermore, what will that do to the situation? Pretty sure God wouldn't be content with being compared to other deities. Speaking of God...

This contradicts literally every Christian tradition of God out there. This confines God to a box, or makes him seem petty, vengeful, and indifferent. Is that not a contradiction of what we are taught? That God is limitless? Why would removing him from school cause this to happen? It implies that God has abandoned us or is punishing us for this, and that should offend every Christian out there. God that is NOT omniscient, omnipotent, and omnipresent? Sounds like it isn't any sort of Christian God.

At the end of the day, the calls will cease. This has been ruled unconstitutional time and time again, and that set the precedent for the future. However, people still call for this change. It's a bad one. It hasn't changed anything. Putting God in a box should irritate any Christian, and anyone who is a proponent of religious liberty should be irked by these proposals, as it oftentimes is nothing except a masquerade for introducing Christianity into schools under the guise of the vague "God." Best way to affect change is to change legislation. Let's do that.

Cover Image Credit: Wikimedia Commons

Popular Right Now

I'm Tired Of Trendy Christianity

Life with Jesus is so much more than one big coffee break.

Okay, you're a Christian. After all, you have all of the tools you need.

You have your densely highlighted and underlined Bible, your Eno, your Chacos, your Patagonia backpack and of course, your beloved Camelbak or Nalgene water bottle that is covered in name-brand stickers.

Your days consist of going outside, chilling in your Eno and blasting "Oceans" by Hillsong and "Good, Good Father" by Chris Tomlin. Your room is decorated with lots of inspirational quotes, maps with variations of "send me" close by and probably some pictures of your last mission trip. Your Instagram page is full of pictures of your friends that are "gems," captions of how thankful you are for certain things and pictures of the last country you visited that say "take me back."

Oh, and you might have a tattoo in Greek.

Okay, if you know me, you know that I literally just described myself. So, when I say what I'm about to, I'm not bashing anyone at all. I am guilty of all of these things and God has really laid these things on my heart that I've found myself doing time after time.

It seems that in the time we live in, if you're going to be a Christian, you have to have all of the right things, and I'm tired of it. Christianity is not about having a certain look or personality, but about having a deep, meaningful relationship with Christ. I think a lot of people have the wrong idea about what being in a relationship with Christ actually looks like. I'm here to tell you that it's not anything like what I described.

Being in a relationship with Christ is not easy, and it's certainly not the most trendy thing out there (maybe on your college campus, but not in the real world.) It's about surrendering everything you have to a God who sent his son to be crucified for things you've done wrong.

It's more than just drinking designer coffee and Bible journaling and "being intentional."

It's about finding peace and joy in spending time with our creator. I know a lot of people just like me who fit the stereotype perfectly who have some of the deepest, most meaningful relationships with Christ, but I also know a lot of people who fit the stereotype who are just faking it.

I'm so tired of people who do not know Christ thinking that they have to have a certain look or personality about them and it hinders them from running into the loving arms of Jesus. We've made Christianity a club, and that's not okay. We have taken God's beauty and grace and made a fad out of it.

So, friends, I'm not saying that we can't have these things and still be Christians (because honestly, I like the way I live life with these things I've been given, and this is just who I am,) but I am saying that having these things are not what makes us Christians. So, be careful how you live out your walk.

Are you just doing it to be trendy, or do you have a deep and meaningful relationship with Christ?

Walking with Jesus is more than just a big coffee break.

Photo by Priscilla Du Preez on Unsplash

Cover Image Credit: Tumblr/Psalm Thirty Seven Four

Related Content

Connect with a generation
of new voices.

We are students, thinkers, influencers, and communities sharing our ideas with the world. Join our platform to create and discover content that actually matters to you.

Learn more Start Creating

I'm A Christian Who Practices Yoga And That's Okay

Yoga and Jesus: Is it possible?


I have a confession: I am a Christian who practices yoga daily. I even teach it twice a week. It may not seem like a big deal, but to some, my yoga practice is considered demonic or blasphemous to my faith. I understand why other Christians hold this belief. Yoga is rooted in the Hindu and Buddhist tradition. Christians do not believe in actively practicing any other religion but Christianity, and monotheistic doctrine is 100% scriptural.

But, it is important to remember that in today's Western culture, many of the specifically religious parts of yoga have been stripped to offer a more inclusive approach to the exercises. To be honest, I have never attended a yoga class in which I felt pressured to conform to the ways of another religion. Yoga teachers see the melting pot of races and religions that walk into the studio every day and know that they have to make class inclusive or they won't have any students! I like to compare yoga to the Christmas tree. Christmas trees definitely have pagan origins, but Christians across America put up a Christmas tree to celebrate Jesus' birth. Although we are aware of the original purpose of the tree, we are also aware that such old traditions mean very little to society today. Yoga is a similar situation.

Most Christians who practice yoga know of its origins but also understand that hundreds of years have separated the practice from its original intent.

When I take a yoga class, I have a very specific mindset that I try to enter each time I approach the mat. This has very little to do with "altering my spiritual state." It's more about making sure that I'm getting the most out of each stretch and breath physically so that I am maintaining emotional regulation. All of these benefits, of course, extend to my spiritual life as well. Because my Christian walk is a part of everything I do, Christ has really, truly blessed me in my yoga practice. When I'm going through a flow, I pray, I seek answers, I ask questions. I get to focus on how God holds together all of my operating systems: physical, mental and spiritual.

Yoga is literally medicine. Doctors are starting to prescribe it like a pill. Here are just a few of the countless benefits of having a regular yoga practice:

- increased flexibility

- more effective circulation

- weight loss

- boosts immunity

- better focus

- increased oxygen intake

- sinus relief

- depression/anxiety relief (lots of serotonin!)

- better posture

- natural pain relief (even for menstrual aches and pains!)

- improved metabolism

- lowers blood sugar

- supports connective tissue

-maintains the nervous system

- releases physical and emotional tension

- relieves drug withdrawal symptoms

- prevents loss of bone and cartilage

- increased strength

- relieves insomnia and other sleep problems

For me and millions of others, the amazing benefits of yoga happen not because of calling on any other deity, but because of the strengthening and relaxation that happens when you go through the physical act of yoga. Of course, this physical positivity changes my emotions and spiritual posture with God, but for the better! I walk away physically invigorated, emotionally purged and spiritually more in tune with my Father's voice.

I think that's a really cool thing to experience, but it's not for everyone, and that's okay! If you're a Christian and do not feel inclined to start a yoga practice, that is valid! No true yogi would ever try and force a practice on anyone! But, it's hard to see a lot of my Christian friends bash yoga as "a practice from Hell" or "a way to open up portals" when it's been a Godsend for so many people ailing from things they never thought they would find relief from.

God, through the redemptive grace of Christ, is in the business of making all things new (Revelation 21:5). He can turn ashes into something of magnificent beauty, and I believe He can do it with yoga. Looking back, I can see how God has given me discernment with my practice to know how to worship and serve my God in yoga without compromising my heart in the process. Because of God's clear direction in my life, maintaining my spiritual integrity in yoga has not been hard.

I totally understand that an 800-word article may not change anyone's mind, and that's okay! I just ask everyone who might disagree with me to take into account not only all that I have said, but all that God says in Scripture, and use discernment to make a decision for yourself. I think that's really the heart of yoga today: asking others to consider a different way of observing life while staying completely true to themselves and what they believe.


Related Content

Facebook Comments