The Case Against The Seahawks Trading Earl Thomas

The Case Against The Seahawks Trading Earl Thomas

Seattle cannot afford to lose another veteran star.

The Seattle Seahawks have a serious dilemma on their hands. The decision whether to trade star safety Earl Thomas or not looms over the organization like a raincloud. There are both pros and cons to losing Earl Thomas, but it is clear that the cons outweigh the pros.

The Seahawks have been in a precarious situation ever since the midway point of the 2017 season. The team suffered season-ending injuries to a number of key players in Richard Sherman, Kam Chancellor and top 2017 Seattle pick Malik McDowell before ending the year with a disappointing 9-7 record.

The Seahawks were very tight against the NFL’s salary cap and had to make some moves to clear up space. Defensive end Michael Bennett was traded to the Philadelphia Eagles, cornerbacks Richard Sherman and Jeremy Lane were released, and a number of key players departed in free agency, including defensive tackle Sheldon Richardson, wide receiver Paul Richardson and tight end Jimmy Graham. While cap space was gained, players at key positions were lost, which created a lot of holes for the Seahawks to deal with.

At the end of the season, they had voids at offensive line, pass rush and tight end. Sherman’s subsequent release from the team only created another hole at cornerback. In addition, Seattle currently lacks a second- and third-round pick for the 2018 NFL Draft, which they gave away in the trades for Sheldon Richardson and offensive tackle Duane Brown. Many NFL analysts have suggested that the Seahawks should trade Thomas to regain draft picks and save money since Thomas wishes to be paid handsomely this offseason. While this sounds appealing, there are compelling reasons why Seattle should not give in unless they receive a sizable return in draft picks or standout players.

First of all, Earl Thomas is one of the best safeties in the NFL and is currently in the prime of his career. He is a six-time Pro Bowler, three-time First-team All-Pro, and two-time Second-team All-Pro. A player of that caliber is not easily replaced and it is not ideal to see him on another team. He has suffered injuries at a more consistent rate in recent years, but his play is still solid and not many safeties, if any, can replicate it.

There is also the matter of the current safety market; there are only a few elite ones in the NFL and none are currently free agents. Dealing Thomas will only create another hole for the team at safety. Finally, Thomas has stated that he wants to remain in Seattle and retire there.

Despite telling Dallas Cowboys head coach Jason Garrett to “come get me” at the end of Seattle’s Week 16 game against the team, Thomas later clarified in his post-game interview, saying that he wanted Dallas to acquire him when the Seahawks “kick me to the curb” and stated that he still wanted to be in Seattle.

There are positives to come from trading Earl Thomas, but the Seahawks are much more likely to be on the short end of the stick if such a trade is executed unless they receive a king’s ransom in return.

Cover Image Credit: Merson | Wikimedia Commons

Popular Right Now

Everything The Student Athlete Loses When They Move On From Sports

Enjoy it while it lasts.


We used to call it "flipping the switch." You would go through eight hours of school (somehow) and then your mentality would automatically change. The worries and stress from the school day would dwindle as you put on your cleats and begin to warm up. Anything that was going on in your life didn't matter when you hit the dirt. You create lifelong friendships with the girls you spent every day with for months at a time. Teammates who see you susceptible after a bad game and on cloud nine after one of your bests.

You develop a routine and superstitions. Hitting your bat on the inside of your cleat before you hit, chewing a certain type of gum on the volleyball court, how many times you spin the ball before you shoot a free throw, whatever your quirk was, you 100% believed it would make you play better. You practice in your free time with your dad, devote three to five months of your school year to a team, and play all summer long with your travel team as you live off hotel breakfast. Then one day, it's all over.

It is a feeling that nobody can prepare you for. They say enjoy it while it lasts but you never really understand what you'll be walking away from when you play your last game and hang it up for good. You lose a part of yourself when you're no longer an athlete. I forgot what it feels like to be competitive and be a part of something that is bigger than myself. It has been two years since I've played my last softball game and not a day goes by when I don't miss it. I didn't play because I wanted to go pro or even to the collegiate level, but I played because it was an escape and helped me become who I am.

You begin to forget what it felt like to hit the sweet spot on a bat, what it sounded like to have an audience cheer for you as you stand alone on second base and see your family in the stands, to hear the metal spikes of your cleats on concrete when walking in the dugout. It's simple things about the game you love that brought you pure joy and an escape from the world and the thoughts in your head. Batting practice was always mine. Focusing on nothing but the next pitch and how hard I could hit it.

When you have to watch the game from the other side of the fence, you realize how much pressure you put on yourself when you played. It's just a game. Make as many memories as you can and enjoy every inning because when you leave sports behind you have to find your inner athlete in other things. Create a workout routine, joining a club sport or intramurals, or even becoming a coach. As much as I miss the sport, I am thankful for everything it brought me. It taught me how to be a good friend, respect others around me, and to push myself to discover what I was capable of.

So, enjoy it while it lasts.

Related Content

Connect with a generation
of new voices.

We are students, thinkers, influencers, and communities sharing our ideas with the world. Join our platform to create and discover content that actually matters to you.

Learn more Start Creating

Giannis Antetokounmpo And Christian Yelich Have Put Milwaukee Back On The Map

Two small market teams making sure the world knows who they are


"MVP" is currently being chanted around the city of Milwaukee and the people of Milwaukee aren't just talking about one person. Giannis Antetokounmpo, a forward for the Milwaukee Bucks and Christian Yelich, an outfielder for the Milwaukee Brewers. Giannis is on the path to winning this year's NBA MVP and Yelich, who happened to win the NL MVP last year, is showing no doubts on potentially becoming this year's MVP as well.

Both the Bucks and the Brewers have struggled in the past few years. The Bucks finished their 2013-2014 season with a record of 15-67. On top of that, they have been playing in the BMO Harris Bradley Center for the past couple of decades. The Bradley Center was intentionally built for hockey and not basketball so attending games for the Bucks sometimes had you in the nosebleeds barely seeing what was going on on the court. The Bucks struggled after their 2013-2014 season with records of 41-41 (2014-2015) and 33-49 (2015-2016). Now, the Bucks have recently finished their regular season and moved to the playoffs. From 15-67 just five years ago, to now 60-22 which gave them the best record in the NBA, the number one seed in the East and home-court advantage, Giannis has proved himself as potentially one of the greatest players the NBA and the Bucks franchise will ever see.

The Bucks now have a new arena that opened this season, Fiserv Forum, which is built specifically for the Bucks (and Marquette) instead of hockey. Looking back on the Bucks in their previous years compared to now, the Bucks have sold out every single game this season. Something Milwaukee never thought they would see from being a small market team. From my experience, while working for the Bucks, you can see the difference in the crowd and feel their enthusiasm and excitement radiating off of the fans. And this is all thanks to Mr. Antetokounmpo who is making his mark here in Milwaukee. Giannis has won Eastern Conference Player of the Month for October/November, December, February and March/April and even earned his spot as Eastern Conference captain for the All-Star game this year. Giannis may be considered in his prime right now, but he is only 24-years-old which means he has plenty of time to only make himself better.

The Brewers had won the NL Central Divison back in 2011 but lost to the St. Louis Cardinals in the National League Championship Series. After that, they struggled a bit and haven't won the title since until last year in 2018. He brought the Brewers to the NLCS last season, but unfortunately, they lost to the Los Angeles Dodgers. Yelich had 36 home runs last season and already has eight (as of 4/16/19) this season. He happens to be a great right fielder as well. In last night's (4/15/19) game against the Cardinals, Yelich alone scored three home runs.

Miller Park has been filling up more and more each game of Brewers fans. Being a small market team like their cross-city friends, the Bucks, bringing home an MVP title as well as a division title, it makes everyone aware of their greatness and dedication. The season may have just started back up again, but there is no doubt, if Yelich and his teammates keep playing like they are right now, they will have another shot of making it to the World Series.

Giannis Antetokounmpo and Christian Yelich have brought and will continue to bring excitement and greatness to Milwaukee which is something the city hasn't seen in a while. This era of sports will surely be remembered for a long time by the people of Milwaukee and Wisconsin.

Related Content

Facebook Comments