Cancel Culture Is An Ineffective Relative Of America’s Puritanical Impulses
Start writing a post

Not to be confused with "call-out culture", what was/is "cancel culture"?

Over the past five years on Twitter, the increased use of #canceled has been blowing up our phones and causing discussions about unacceptable societal practices. But what exactly does it mean to be canceled? Though we are entrenched in a constant stream of cancelations, it's helpful to know the definition.

Whereas being "called-out" is marked by public humiliation, being "canceled" takes this call-out a step further. The socially-decided wrongdoings of a party, likely an influencer or celebrity, are exposed so as to terminate the party's career or at least knock their cultural standing down a few pegs.

Metaphorically, he/she is excommunicated. This practice of canceling has been around since the Pilgrims discovered the righteous high the hysteria of pointing fingers in Salem. The historical consequences for cancellations were objectively graver than today.

The implementation of the Internet actually diluted the effectiveness of boycotting because common cancelations are dispersed to an unprecedentedly wide audience with a tiny attention span. The discipline it takes to actually "cancel" someone's cultural cachet by boycott is immense and rare in the hustle-bustle of today. Another factor that waters down our woke mentality as the new Puritanism is that, instead of a concrete list of sins and commandments, modern trespasses are ever-evolving.

The idea of canceling has sociological roots from the intolerance of the colonies, but what we have now is that same tone at a lower volume.

Why do we have the instinct to blame others?

Sorry native English, I had to outsource to find the perfect word to help us understand this feeling of pleasure from learning of someone's downfall.

With a bit of research into linguistics, one finds that German psychologists describe the complex self-satisfaction that comes from witnessing the failures or embarrassments of another as "schadenfreude." This emotion occurs because seeing the mistakes of another person makes us feel better about ourselves.

Schadenfreude is the reason America's Funniest Videos, a show devoted to hilarious compilations of folks getting injured, is still airing. Moreover, schadenfreude is the reason we feel a little giddy when our trash ex is going through a bad breakup on a public platform. Finally, schadenfreude is why we love to grab that virtual pitchfork and send a tweet with the angry online mob.

Fascinatingly, the lower someone's self-esteem is and the younger someone is, the more that person is affected by schadenfreude because the sensation gives one a boost of confidence knowing someone's doing worse than him/her. What other qualities encapsulate my competitive generation, the social media natives, better than insecure and youthful?

Does cancel culture even work?

Not like it's designed, in most cases. Very few individuals actually suffer career setbacks. Empirically, we can measure this by looking at the yearly salaries and new projects of supposedly "canceled" celebrities.

For instance, after Louis CK admitted to sex crimes, he was dropped by his agency. However, he recently went on a sold-out live tour of comedy shows, including one-stop where he recorded his new special, "Sincerely." Another comedian who allegedly committed sexual misconduct, Aziz Ansari, released a Netflix special Right Now, that many have described as a "comeback." With his financially-successful Road to Nowhere tour, Ansari had already proven that people would pay to see him perform despite the scandal. Justice Brett Kavanaugh was "canceled" after Christine Blasey Ford testified that he had sexually assaulted her, yet he was immediately confirmed to the Supreme Court after the trial. Americans were appalled and quick to "cancel" Donald Trump after they heard him on tape boasting about his sex crimes, yet he acts as the Commander-in-Chief today. So, yes - while some powerful men may not have the same sacrosanct statuses, they have hardly been "canceled."

It should be noted that cancelations are not limited to the bounds of the #MeToo Movement, for instance, Kathy Griffin was bashed for her infamous 2017 photograph in which she held up a Donald Trump mask covered with fake blood. It shocked everyone from Sean Hannity to Anderson Cooper, and some critics compared Griffin to a terrorist. However, Griffin is hardly suffering monetarily as she just bought a $10.5 million dollar home in cash and has a new documentary, Kathy Griffin: A Hell of a Story. Don't even get me started on the Internet community, whose celebrities like Shane Dawson and James Charles, have been "canceled" and reinstated so many times that no one can keep track of our own fickle feelings. All of these examples prove the rule that modern canceling is not as chaotically harsh as the word connotes.

What's my point?

To clarify, the thesis of this article is not an indignant advocation that cancelations must be more severe, so as to match our colonial ancestors. After all, even Barack Obama held that dogmatically refusing to cut our fellow humans slack is harmful. However, the point of this article is to express the place that canceling has in our society and to reveal from where the dark impulse to hurt others comes.

Today, the term has been used in a multitude of manifestations to the point in which 'canceled' has been rendered meaningless. In all, the distracted and watered-down version of canceling that we have today precludes a nuanced dialogue of the specific harm done to real victims and how those with privilege who made the mistake ought to be held accountable.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.

23 Pandemic-Approved Date Ideas That'll Send Sparks Flying From Six Feet Apart

There's a safe way to date right now and yes, it includes masks.


While some people would rather opt out of dating altogether during the pandemic so they don't have to wear a mask on a first date, others are choosing to listen to both guidelines and their heart in order to find love during the time of coronavirus (COVID-19).

Should you be one of the individuals welcoming romance right now, there are pandemic-approved dates you can go on that still adhere to guidelines (and yes, you'll have to wear a mask).

Keep Reading... Show less

20 Books About Latin And Hispanic Heritage Absolutely Everyone Should Have On Their Bookshelf

Any ally of the community needs to be reading these incredible reads.


I go through phases when it comes to what I like to read. I am typically reading two books at any given time: one serious nonfiction and one escapist fiction novel to have on hand and open up depending on my mood.

What remains consistent, however, amongst most of my fellow bibliophiles is a desire to try new and different authors and genres. I, as an Indian woman, have been partial to reading books written by fellow Indian and Desi writers since I first got a library card.

Keep Reading... Show less

In our patriarchal society, men hide from their feelings, but toxic masculinity is literally killing men. They swallow the pain and move on so that they can look, feel, and act "tough."

But, strength is derived from asking for help and voicing your struggle and, trust me, working on your mental health is one hell of a struggle. The real way to "man up" is to acknowledge the downfalls in unjust societal norms. Mental health problems do not mean that a man is weak, they are neurologically-based disorders that require professional treatment.

Keep Reading... Show less
Health and Wellness

I Asked 46 Women What They Thought About The Term 'Plus-Size', And Here's What They Had To Say

It's 2020, where change is inevitable and norms are not only questioned, but challenged.


We live in a world where it's become customary to push boundaries, break rules, and question standards upheld by society. Though try as we might, some of these standards are harder to conquer than others — body image is one of the top contenders.

For years, the body positivity movement has pushed for the acceptance of all marginalized body types not represented or celebrated in the media. Recently, we've gotten better at appreciating and accepting all body types, but one thing that's still lingering is the stigma of body image in the fashion industry — more specifically, the term "plus-size."

Keep Reading... Show less
Politics and Activism

Sorry, But 'I Don’t Care About Politics' Is Not A Valid Excuse For NOT Voting

The younger generation of voters is so crucial to the upcoming election because our vote is going to shape the world that we are about to enter as adults.


When I ask my friends if they are voting this term most of them respond with "no" followed by an explanation of "I don't care enough," "It doesn't affect me," or "I don't keep up with politics," etc. I get it, as a college student I know that there are many other things to be concerned about like school, relationships, work, and friends. I also understand that keeping up with politics can seem like trying to keep up with an over-exaggerated reality show that has way too many seasons. Not to mention most news stations and websites are biased so it's hard to decipher if what you hear is true or fake.

However, despite all of this annoyance, as the next generation of Americans, we have to remember that we owe it to ourselves, our families, and to our futures to care.

Keep Reading... Show less

Taylor Swift Sang 'betty' At The ACMs And It Was The Perfect First Live 'folklore' Performance

I guarantee that Inez is spreading rumors about how fire this performance was.


The Academy of Country Music Awards were last night and the performances were wonderful, but Taylor Swift's live version of "betty" from her newest album "folklore" really took the cake for me.

Keep Reading... Show less
Photo by Anna Hernández-Buces

"Do you have big parties on Cinco de Mayo?"

Keep Reading... Show less
Health and Wellness

9 Reasons I Unfollowed All The Fitness Influencers On My Instagram Feed

I don't need to feel bad about myself because of who I follow on social media.


Throughout quarantine, something that a lot of us picked up on was working out. With all the free time, it seemed like the perfect opportunity to work on that "dream bod" you've been wanting for years, or to just feel good about yourself.

A common way to stay motivated and keep yourself on-task is to follow fitness influencers on various platforms. For some people, yes, this can be a healthy and helpful way to keep your drive. In other cases, however, this can do more harm than good.

Keep Reading... Show less

The Ultimate Guide To Being A Latinx And Hispanic Community Ally

Educate and celebrate their culture to lift the community up.


It's well known that the Gen-Z and millennial generations are more passionate about social justice and conscious about their decisions as consumers as any other generation to come before us.

For these generations, making mindful decisions about where we like to allocate our money, who we choose to follow on Instagram, and even the books we like to read are extremely important to us. With the rise of the digital age, we are constantly consuming media and content, and so there's no longer an excuse for being uneducated if we want to be educated on a wide range of cultures.

Keep Reading... Show less

It was a day we all knew would possibly come but hoped it never would. The day the outbreak hit.

I remember, back in March, I was just about to return home from a socially distanced vacation in my Florida home with my mom and grandpa, when my dad called to tell us he was feeling sick. At the time, President Trump hadn't closed the borders, my school was still going back after Easter, and sheer panic hadn't yet flooded our news outlets. We were meant to return home on Saturday, but when the borders closed on Thursday, things got a little more serious.

Keep Reading... Show less

21 Romance Novels You'll Fall In Love With By The Fire

It's time to cozy up and fantasize about our fav fictional love stories.


Recently, I found myself reading a bunch of romance novels and it's truly unleashing the romantic side of me. With fall weather nearing, it's the perfect time to cozy up with a good book and ignite the romantic flame in your hearts with the turn of every page.

Here are 21 romantic books you should read this fall, some I've read (hence the reviews), and some I'm hoping to get my hands on.

Keep Reading... Show less

There is a lot going on in the world right now, much of which is contributing to the mental health crisis we've found ourselves in. While it would be fantastic to snap our fingers and jump out of our rut, that's not exactly how these things work. Thankfully, small, sustainable steps can make a huge difference in your mental wellbeing.

Keep Reading... Show less

These 10 Oversized Graphic Tees Are JUST As Cute As Urban Outfitters — And They're All Under $30

There is never a bad time to get some new oversized graphic tees, especially when they're all under $30.


While we all love Urban Outfitters' graphic tees, it can be hard to justify a $40 T-shirt, so I am always on the hunt to find cheaper alternatives that are just as stylish! Thrifting is always an option for authentic, vintage tees, but we don't always have the time to search through the endless aisles of Goodwill.

Lucky for you, there are still affordable alternatives that don't require quite as much effort.

Keep Reading... Show less

On Monday, "Dancing with the Stars" returned to our televisions with their 29th season. This season featured a lot of different changes including a new host, a new judge as well as a new judging system.

Among these changes, there were also changes to account for the coronavirus pandemic. Some of these changes included practicing socially distancing as well as different filming practices.

Keep Reading... Show less
Facebook Comments