Stop Using The 'Model Minority' Stereotype To Argue Asian-Americans Aren't People Of Color

Stop Using The 'Model Minority' Stereotype To Argue Asian-Americans Aren't People Of Color

The model minority myth has been used to discredit and degrade other minority groups speaking up about discrimination and racism.


In discussions of racism and people of color in the United States, it often seems like Asian Americans are left out. The general perception of Asians as a minority is that they may face discrimination, but someone always has it worse, or in many cases, Asian Americans are not regarded as a marginalized group at all. I've even heard a friend, who is Asian American herself, tell me that discrimination against Asian Americans "isn't really a thing."

Some will even claim that Asian-Americans are not people of color. All of this leads back to the model minority myth.

The model minority myth claims that Asian Americans are successful and thriving in the United States, which is what makes them the "model minority." This is linked to common stereotypes about Asians, such as "all Asians are smart" or "Asians are good at math." The model minority myth has been used to discredit and degrade other minority groups speaking up about discrimination and racism, most prominently in that of African Americans during the Civil Rights Movement. The idea is that Asian Americans are more hardworking and disciplined, proving that minority groups can succeed in the United States and that it's not racism that is holding them back. The use of the model minority myth is only an attempt to degrade other minorities who speak up about their discrimination and to excuse and cover up racism in the United States. This creates a divide between Asian Americans and other groups: Asian Americans are put on this pedestal, while it is implied that other racial minorities are somehow less deserving.

This, of course, is false.

Racism is very much an issue in the United States, and it still affects Asian Americans no matter how much those who use the model minority myth like to think otherwise. In fact, Asian Americans are actually least likely to be promoted to management positions due to stereotypes that Asians are less assertive and more passive.

Ironically, the model minority myth, while attempting to elevate Asian Americans as a successful minority, contributes to many of the difficulties and discrimination faced by Asian Americans. The idealization of Asians perpetuates stereotypes and puts unnecessary pressure on Asian Americans, especially at a young age, as well as giving credit to their race for any success they have rather than their work as individuals. And because this myth diminishes the issue of racism against them, Asians are not seen as an underrepresented group by many and are not given much attention in any programs or efforts for diversity, when in fact, this is not the case at all.

In Hollywood, Asians only make up about one percent of all leading roles. Furthermore, a recent study shows that Asian Americans suffer the most, in terms of impact on their well-being, from racism and discrimination. This is likely due to the belief that Asian Americans are a less marginalized group. Consequently, racism and discrimination not commonly brought up in Asian American households and Asian Americans are not as prepared to face these issues, causing a greater negative effect on their emotional well-being.

There is no value or weight to the model minority myth: it is harmful to both Asian Americans and the minorities they are compared to. It only serves to further isolate Asians from other minorities, and unfortunately, in many cases, it works. It is important to include Asian Americans in conversations about racism and discrimination. These issues are just as real for us. The model minority myth is nothing more than that: a myth.

Popular Right Now

17 Signs You Grew Up Irish

Irish and proud!

With a name like Shannon Elizabeth Ryan many people right away sarcastically ask the question "you're not Irish are you?" I always laugh and jokingly say nope not at all. I'm extremely proud of my Irish heritage, but what does it mean to be Irish?

Here are 17 signs you grew up Irish:

1. You have a distinct Irish name: first or last

Shannon, Elizabeth, Michael, Patrick, Sean, James, Ryan, Riley, Mahony, Murphy. Extra points if your last name begins with O', Mac or Mc.

2. You have been called a "potato head" or towhead as a child

Shannon Ryan

"What a bunch or potato heads!" Meaning you were really Irish or really blonde or both.

3. You were raised Catholic

Shannon Ryan

Catholic school, mass every Sunday. Oh and you were most likely an alter server or in the choir and can say the mass forward and backwards.

4. You have a love for potatoes of any kind.

Also, you may have read this book about a potato as a child.

5. You've been told, "Oh, you're Irish, you can hold your drinks."


I mean it's in your blood, right?

6. Funeral, wedding, birthday you really can't tell the difference

Wedding? Get the whiskey. Oh, you said funeral?

... get the whiskey.

7. You know old Irish Songs and sing along with every note

"The Streets of New York," "Black Velvet Band," "Wild Rover," "Molly Malone," "Galway Girl," "Danny Boy," tell me ma all songs I remember being singing along with as a kid.

8. Your favorite holiday is St. Patrick's Day and you go all out

A day to show the world that there are only two types of people in the world: those who are Irish and those that wish they were.

9. You own a Celtic cross, Claddagh ring or any Irish knot jewelry and wear it often

You were most likely given that Celtic cross when you were born and got one for your First Holy Communion. The Claddagh was given by someone who loves you and Irish knots you can never go wrong with.

10. Two words: "soda" and "bread"

Some don't know that the cross made on the top of bread is to keep the devil away and protect the house.

11. You have a HUGE family and the parties and reunions that go along with it are just as big

My family is enormous and this is only half of it and I still don't know everyone.

12. There is no such thing as tanning

Unless you ware one of the blessed ones who do tan I'm extremely jealous. For the rest of us, we have two options pale or red there is no in-between.

13. You may not have the cleanest mouth or quietest voice

But you would never dare say a bad word in front of someone older than you. As for an indoor voice, it's non-existent.

14. You can successfully pull off an “Irish Exit" and then have to explain to your friends the next day what exactly that is when they ask where you went

Basically means you leave the party without anyone knowing.

15. At one point in your life, you've said, “Jesus, Mary, and Joseph" if something went wrong

I heard this a lot growing up and I catch myself saying it every now and again.

16. The only college football team you root for is Notre Dame

I mean is there any other, Let's Go Fighting Irish!

17. Lastly, you are extremely proud of your Irish heritage

We are Irish. We are taught to be strong, have faith in God and learn how to party and have fun. Erin Go Bragh!

Cover Image Credit:

Related Content

Connect with a generation
of new voices.

We are students, thinkers, influencers, and communities sharing our ideas with the world. Join our platform to create and discover content that actually matters to you.

Learn more Start Creating

I Won't Forgive The Anti-Semitic Students Of Spain Park, Not Yet

Maybe it isn't time for an apology.


I am Jewish. It is something I have never been afraid of and something I value as much in life as I do with my family and friends. Throughout my life, though I have witnessed hate of the Jewish people and jokes made about Jewish people.

In high school, I had to listen to jokes about Jews and the gas chambers and was asked because I was Jewish if I could do someone else's math homework.

To say I had to deal with anti-Semitism in the South does not come close to describing what I had to go through. As time went by the jokes stopped and I thought I would not have to deal with instances of prejudice or bigotry but I was wrong. Growing up as one of the only Jewish people in my friend group and in high school it made me consider myself strong and ready for college but in my freshman year I had to go through other jokes about my religion and even in sophomore year had to witness someone I thought was my friend make a joke about my religion because "he thought it was funny."

I let the instances of anti-Semitism serve as times when I could prove people wrong I learned to forgive and forget.

But I had to witness other acts of hate towards Judaism while in college. From swastikas on a fraternity house, a synagogue shooting, the BDS movement and more hate speech, the hate towards Jews have seemed to grow and I do not understand why. I get hurt each time I hear of an instance but it has not allowed me to view my Judaism any differently. However, there was an occurrence that has affected me in a different way.

It happened in my home state and it has not sat well with me.

On Monday a video surfaced of multiple high school students making anti-Semitic and anti-Black comments. The video featured a guy turning around the camera multiple times to show he was laughing and thought it was funny while others made comments about concentration camps, what would happen if Jews ruled the world and asking what the world would be like without the Holocaust. The students were from Spain Park in Birmingham and have gathered quite a reputation online.

To say I am filled with anger, disappointment, and embarrassment is an understatement.

This is my home state and these students are not only disrespecting the Jewish and Black people in the state of Alabama but throughout the US and possibly even in the world. I am hurt by this instance but I am not ready to forgive these students just yet.

After the video was leaked online some of the students sent messages to the person who uploaded the video apologizing. That I took as a mature gesture until I read the apology from the girl in the video. The apology asked if the user could remove the video because it would ruin her life and reputation. It was later found out that the female student is the daughter of the manager of the Toyota dealership in Hoover after the manager posted an apology.

Any remorse I had going for these students was now gone.

They were not sorry. They were sorry that they got caught and were facing consequences. They gave the apology that your parents made you say when you did not want to apologize. They did not care about who they had harmed or what they had said, they cared because they had to face consequences and they know that this mistake would follow them for the rest of their life.

I'm at a loss for words.

I don't know how to feel. I know someone will tell me I am overreacting but how am I supposed to approach this? What they said was wrong and there is no proper way to express frustration for it. I know people get offended by certain things but some things are not meant to be a joke. So I hope what you said was worth it and was fun to say because it will follow you for the rest of your life. Some lessons are best-learned overtime and it looks like you will have a chance to reflect on these events.

Related Content

Facebook Comments