The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion: Now if you never took the time to play this one, you really should. I prefer the storyline in this game over Skyrim. Skyrim has a lot to offer but so does this game. You deal with closing the gates of hell, basically. If you get the DLC, Shivering Isles, you get to go into an actual world created by a daedric prince. All I'm saying is that this game never got enough credit like Skyrim did.
The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim: This game has been one of the best games created and is the most played game throughout the gaming community. I recommend this game because of the graphics and just how much there is to do. I've spent over 100 hours on Skyrim and I'm still not done everything. Also, for them to make a remastered version for the new-gen consoles, is really saying something about the game.
Bioshock Infinite: Out of all the Bioshocks, I recommend playing this one. The storyline in this game is so much more than it seems. It took me 3 playthroughs to finally understand the ending to the game. The graphics are very cartoonish but they still amaze me. Also if you like religion and political conspiracies, this is a game for you.
The Last of Us: Zombies. Enough said. No really, though. This game is more than just a zombie game. The storyline is absolutely beautiful and kind of depressing. Not only that, you follow the story of just a normal man who lost his daughter and is now taking care of another child who is a resemblance of his daughter in certain ways. It really shows the emotion and action that should be in a game.
The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings: The reason I'm recommending this game is because I never found something that peaked my interest like Skyrim did until I played this game. I absolutely loved the whole concept, from the storyline to the characters and even the fact you could change the outcome of the ending. I literally fell in love with the characters in this game. Also, it's sort of an open world game but not really, once you leave the castle, you can't go back to pick up anything you missed, which kind of sucks. But overall, this game was one of my favorites that I finished.
Heavy Rain: I personally loved this game because of how many endings were possible and how there were different characters. The storyline was also amazing and sad. The graphics were very realistic and I was drawn in from the moment the game started with a dad playing with his two sons before their birthday party. I recommend this game if you love mysteries.